Page 2 of 3
The number and format of a critique group can take many
variations. I have been a member of critique groups ranging from two members to
a hundred, groups that “met” online every week, and others that met every three
weeks in the leader’s living room.
My writing has improved through receiving critiques, critiquing
other writers’ work, and listening to the feedback given to other writers. We
also share resources — tips we’ve learned from writing workshops, good
books on writing, examples from great fiction, and tips on getting published.
What I like best about my current group is the professionalism
and hard work everyone puts into giving feedback. Everyone in the group loves
writing, and wants each other to succeed. Giving — and receiving —
feedback takes practice. It is important to let the writer know specific areas
that need work without making the writer feel attacked. Writers receiving
feedback need to learn to listen and be ready to make changes — otherwise
why bother bringing your work in the first place?
On Sept. 13 at the Whistler Readers and Writers Festival, Pam
Barnsley and I will share some of the tips about giving feedback that we’ve
been lucky enough to learn through our critique group. In Feedback Blitz
– How to Give and Receive Feedback, we’ll discuss tips for what to look
for when giving feedback and how to receive feedback and use it (or not) in your
revision. We’ll also give tips on how to create a critique group, and will be
available to help any interested writers get started with creating one.
Writers coming to the session are encouraged to bring a short
piece of writing — up to two pages — in order for us to practise
giving and receiving feedback in a friendly atmosphere. If you don’t have
anything ready for critique that’s okay, come and practise giving feedback.
One of the goals of the Vicious Circle is to be an umbrella
organization to support smaller critique groups. We now have one working
critique group and are working with a few interested people to start a second
group. We hope that any writers out there interested in joining a critique
group will attend the Feedback Blitz session.
How do you know if you’re ready to be part of a critique group?
All you need is to be willing to work at your writing and to spend time giving
honest feedback to the other members of your group. Writing is a learning
process that never ends. By learning to give and receive feedback you’ll be
tuned in to areas in which your writing can grow that you might never have seen
otherwise, and soon you’ll have that piece polished and ready to send to your